Bagel Supreme
284, Park Avenue, Rutherford
Bagel Supreme is a local cafe located in Rutherford. Check in here with the Pulled Coffee app to earn real cash rewards. Independent cafes count toward all challenges including Pulled 50 through Pulled 300.
Add Bagel Supreme to your coffee map in Rutherford. This neighborhood cafe is one of the stops Pulled members log to earn real rewards on everyday spending. A single photo of your drink checks you in, and the visit feeds your challenges from the first cup.
This is the sort of cafe that anchors a block. Expect an unfussy menu, steady service, and a space that works whether you are passing through or settling in. The coffee is dependable and the welcome is genuine. It is a practical, pleasant stop, the kind of place you end up returning to because it quietly does the job well.
Find it in Rutherford. As coffee in Rutherford goes, it is an accessible stop that pairs well with the spots around it, so a single outing can cover more than one check-in. That makes it a smart addition to your map whether you are a regular in the area or just passing through for the day.
First visit to Bagel Supreme? Keep it simple. Ask what is popular, pick the size that matches your morning, and find a seat if you have the time. There is no wrong order here. The app rewards the cup either way, so drink what you came for and let the check-in take care of itself.
The more places you log, the fuller your map and the closer your next payout.
RECENT PULLS
No pulls yet. Be the first to check in here.
Check in at Bagel Supreme.
Earn real cash. Visit this shop, take a photo of your drink. That is it.
600 founding spots remaining. Half-price lifetime pricing.
MORE IN RUTHERFORD
MORE CAFES IN US
EDITORIALS IN US
Are you the owner of Bagel Supreme?
Claim this shop to verify ownership, respond to check-ins, and run sponsored challenges to Pulled's community.
Claim Bagel Supreme →